Bulho Labs

Goodlight · data · hosts

Hosts with one listing get better reviews than the big managers.

We grouped 11,375 listings in Portugal by host. Those with a single place beat those with ten or more on every Airbnb review category. They lose on one thing: photos.

Data from · By Bulho Labs

Goodlight · Infographic

Bulho Labs

4.2×

more often a Guest Favourite with 1 listing than with 10 or more

  • 52%

    of single-listing hosts are rated 4.9 or above

  • 28%

    of managers with 10 or more are rated 4.9 or above

  • 49%

    of small hosts have weak photos (managers: 23%)

11,375 listings · 6,458 hosts · Portugal · Nov 2026Download image ↓Social post format ↓
6,458
hosts in the sample
74%
have a single listing
15%
of listings belong to 76 managers with 10 or more
4.2×
more often a Guest Favourite: 1 listing vs 10 or more

01 —

Many small hosts, a few big managers

Three in four hosts have a single listing. But the 76 who run ten or more (the largest has 119 in our sample) hold 15% of all listings. The top 1% of hosts by size hold 14%.

Hosts and listings, by how many listings the host has

  • 1 listing
  • 2–3
  • 4–9
  • 10 or more
  • Hosts74%19%
  • Listings42%24%19%15%
See the data
Host's listingsHostsListings
1 listing4,773 (74%)4,773 (42%)
2–31,209 (19%)2,785 (24%)
4–9400 (6%)2,108 (19%)
10 or more76 (1%)1,709 (15%)

02 —

The bigger the manager, the lower the rating

Among listings with at least five reviews, more than half of single-listing hosts are at 4.9 or above. For managers with ten or more, only 28%. And one in seven of those managers' listings is below 4.5, five times as many as for single hosts.

The average drops from 4.86 to 4.71. That looks small, but on Airbnb nearly every listing sits between 4.7 and 5: the gap decides who shows up as a Guest Favourite.

Overall rating, by how many listings the host has

Airbnb listings with at least 5 reviews.

  • Below 4.5
  • 4.5 to 4.79
  • 4.8 to 4.89
  • 4.9 or above
  • 1 listing19%25%52%
  • 2–323%25%49%
  • 4–926%25%44%
  • 10 or more15%35%22%28%
See the data
ListingsRatedAverage< 4.54.5–4.794.8–4.89≥ 4.9
1 listing3,7434.862.7%19.4%25.4%52.4%
2–32,1904.853.8%22.5%25.1%48.6%
4–91,4914.826.2%25.5%24.7%43.6%
10 or more1,1604.7114.5%35.3%22.2%27.9%

Guest Favourite and Superhost

Share of listings with the Guest Favourite badge (5+ reviews) and of Superhost hosts.

  • Guest Favourite
  • Superhost
  • 1 listing20%50%
  • 2–316%60%
  • 4–912%53%
  • 10 or more5%25%
See the data
ListingsGuest FavouriteSuperhost
1 listing20%50%
2–316%60%
4–912%53%
10 or more5%25%

03 —

Where the rating is lost

The gap is smallest on location: both groups' listings are on the same streets. It's largest on what depends on a person: communication, check-in and value.

A likely reason: a host with one place answers the messages themselves and knows the home; a manager with dozens of homes often works through teams, automated messages and key boxes. The data shows the gap, not the cause.

Airbnb's six categories: 1 listing vs 10 or more

Average of each category, listings with at least 5 reviews. The scale starts at 4.55 to show the distance between the two groups.

  • 1 listing
  • 10 or more
Communication
Check-in
Accuracy
Cleanliness
Location
Value
4.604.704.804.90
See the data
Category1 listing10 or moreGap
Communication4.924.760.15
Check-in4.894.750.14
Accuracy4.884.770.11
Cleanliness4.864.750.10
Location4.824.770.05
Value4.794.630.16

04 —

What managers do better: photos

Half of single-listing hosts have photos our automatic check flags as weak (dark, soft or small). For managers with ten or more, 23%. It is the one measure where managers clearly win. They also write in English in 83% of their listings.

Small hosts charge more (median nightly price €125 against €115) and have twice the reviews (38 against 18). They win where the stay happens and fall behind on the first impression, which is the photo.

Photos, language and replies: 1 listing vs 10 or more

  • 1 listing
  • 10 or more
  • Photos flagged as weak49%23%
  • Description in English41%83%
  • Replies to 100% of messages91%80%
  • No reviews yet7%13%
See the data
1 listing10 or more
Photos flagged as weak49%23%
Description in English41%83%
Replies to 100% of messages91%80%
No reviews yet7%13%

05 —

What this means if you have one place

  1. 01 —

    Your advantage is in the reviews

    Communication, check-in and value are where small hosts stand out most. Keep your replies quick and personal.

  2. 02 —

    Your weak spot is the photos

    Half of small hosts have weak photos. They're the first thing a guest sees and the easiest thing to fix.

  3. 03 —

    Write in English too

    Managers write in English in over 80% of their listings. If you host foreign guests, a bilingual description reaches more of them.

Method and limits

Sample: 11,375 Airbnb and Booking listings in more than 30 towns and cities in Portugal, collected in October and November 2026, grouped into 6,458 hosts by host id, tax number or contact. Ratings, badges and categories come from Airbnb only (10,977 listings); rating averages use listings with at least 5 reviews.

The number of listings is what we found in our sample, not the host's full portfolio: a manager with 10 listings here may have 200 across the country. The larger groups are therefore undercounted, not overcounted.

This is an association, not a cause: managers' listings differ in many ways (fewer reviews, smaller homes, different towns). We also don't know how many bookings each listing gets. "Weak photos" come from an automatic measurement of light, sharpness and size, with no AI. We don't publish any individual listing or host.

Want to see what we'd find in your listing?

We look through your listing's photos and fix two of them for free. No strings attached.