Bulho Labs

Ebook · paid · €10

The complete listing

Airbnb and Booking.com from start to finish: search, title and text, amenities, ratings, pricing, settings and programmes. With the platforms' exact rules, the arithmetic worked out and the numbers from 8,577 Portuguese listings.

51%of listings have “value” as their weakest category

Secure payment by Stripe · Invoice by email · PT and EN

Goodlight · €10

The complete listing

01 —

What's inside

  1. 01Where you stand: the Portuguese benchmarkBefore you change anything, compare your listing with 8,577 Portuguese listings: what rating is normal, which category tends to be the weakest, and how many listings hold each badge.
  2. 02How Airbnb search decides, and the mythsWhat Airbnb says counts, what its engineers have published about how search works inside, and a verdict on the advice that circulates.
  3. 03Title and the first lines of the descriptionThe title rules Airbnb published in February 2026, what to put in the first lines of the description, and why text length does not separate good listings from the rest.
  4. 04Amenities: the cheapest fixAmenities are the part of a listing machines read most. Ticking what exists takes minutes; leaving it unticked costs you in four places.
  5. 05The arithmetic of a ratingHow many five-star reviews it takes to move up, what one four-star review costs, and why on Booking the sum is in months, not in review counts.
  6. 06Guest Favourite, Top % and Superhost: what is publishedAirbnb's badges have written criteria and criteria that are written nowhere. Telling them apart saves you working towards a number that does not exist.
  7. 07Value and accuracy: what tracks the overall ratingThe two categories that track the overall rating most are not about being cheap or having everything. They are about what the guest expected and what they found.
  8. 08Cleanliness, comfort and check-in: the home itselfThe cleaning standard Airbnb publishes, what separates a three-star review from a four, what changes with the seasons in Portugal, and a message schedule.
  9. 09Reviews: asking, replying, removingBoth platforms' rules side by side, what Airbnb's experiments show about asking for reviews, and reply templates.
  10. 10Airbnb pricing and settingsThe 15.5% fee with the sums worked out, the thresholds at which a discount becomes visible, the new-listing promotion, automatic pricing, and each setting with what Airbnb says it does.
  11. 11Booking.com: ranking, scores and programmesWhat Booking says orders its results, the property page score and the quality rating, the programmes with their criteria, and what they really cost.
  12. 12The master checklistEverything in this guide as one list to work through with your listing open, and at the end what the evidence does not show.

02 —

Where each claim comes from

Every claim in the book carries a number pointing to its source. This is the mix of sources, by type.

03 —

Read a whole chapter

01 — Chapter

Where you stand: the Portuguese benchmark

Before you change anything, compare your listing with 8,577 Portuguese listings: what rating is normal, which category tends to be the weakest, and how many listings hold each badge.

Between 31 October and 12 November 2026 we collected the public data of Airbnb listings in about 40 Portuguese towns. Of these, 8,577 had at least five reviews and all six category ratings visible [1]. They are the basis of this chapter. It is not a random sample of Portugal (see "How this was made"), so we always read the numbers as "in the listings we analysed".

4.83

average overall rating across the 8,577 listings

15.7%

hold the Guest Favourite badge

57.8%

have a Superhost

51.0%

have value as their lowest category

Goodlight, 8,577 Airbnb listings with ≥ 5 reviews, Portugal, Nov 2026 [1].

A 4.8 is an average result, not an excellent one. In our listings, 71.4% are rated 4.80 or higher and 46.6% are rated 4.90 or higher [1]. Airbnb says the same worldwide: in 2024, 85% of reviews were five stars and the average listing was rated over 4.75 [14].

The six categories

CategoryAverageCorrelation with overallLowest in
Communication4.8820.747.9%
Check-in4.8620.6712.4%
Accuracy4.8540.858.0%
Cleanliness4.8400.7716.7%
Location4.8170.5132.8%
Value4.7510.8551.0%

Goodlight, 8,577 Airbnb listings with ≥ 5 reviews, Portugal, Nov 2026 [1]. Ties count for each category, so the last column adds up to more than 100%.

Two things stand out. Value is the lowest category for half of the listings and, together with accuracy, it tracks the overall rating most closely (correlation 0.85 each) [1]. Cleanliness, which many guides put first, is the lowest for only 16.7%. In a US study by an inspection vendor, cleanliness was the weakest for 27.8% of listings and value for 34.0% [55]: the methods differ, so take the Portuguese figures as ours and the US ones as context.

By rating band

Overall ratingListingsGuest FavouriteSuperhostMedian €/night
4.95 or more2,55041.6%71.5%142
4.90–4.941,45014.9%78.8%111
4.85–4.891,2364.5%68.9%102
4.80–4.848921.0%56.5%98
4.70–4.791,0340.5%41.9%88
4.50–4.699700%17.3%85
under 4.54450%8.5%75

Goodlight, 8,577 Airbnb listings with ≥ 5 reviews, Portugal, Nov 2026 [1]. Price for one stay about 30 days after collection (early December): low-season prices, not a town benchmark.

Overall ratingAccuracyCleanlinessLocationValue
4.95 or more4.964.964.894.89
4.90–4.944.924.914.864.83
4.85–4.894.894.874.834.79
4.80–4.844.854.834.804.74
4.70–4.794.804.774.784.67
4.50–4.694.704.664.714.55
under 4.54.414.414.564.21

Category averages in each band, same sample [1].

From the 4.70–4.79 band to 4.95 and above, value rises 0.22, cleanliness 0.19, accuracy 0.16, communication 0.14, check-in 0.13 and location 0.11 [1]. The highest-rated listings charge more, not less (median €142 against €88), tick more amenities and show more photos [1]. It is a snapshot: it shows what highly rated listings look like, not what moved any one listing's rating.

Small hosts and managers

Host's listingsAverage ratingGuest FavouriteSuperhost
14.86420.2%50.2%
2–34.84716.0%59.9%
4–94.81912.4%53.4%
10 or more4.7124.8%25.4%

Goodlight, 11,375 listings from 6,458 hosts, Portugal, Nov 2026; ratings of listings with ≥ 5 reviews [7].

Hosts with a single listing are associated with higher ratings in every category than managers with ten or more, most of all in communication (4.915 against 4.762) and value (4.787 against 4.630) [7]. We do not know why; it may be attention, it may be the type of home. But it means a small host does not start at a disadvantage.

Where your listing stands

  • Write down your overall rating and number of reviews (at the top of the listing).
  • Open the reviews and note the six category averages.
  • Mark the lowest category and its distance from your overall rating.
  • Compare with the row for your band in the tables above.
  • If value is the lowest, read chapter 7 first; if cleanliness, chapter 8; if accuracy, chapters 3, 4 and 7.

Secure payment by Stripe · Invoice by email · PT and EN

04 —

Questions

What format is it?
An A4 PDF to print or read on screen, plus the online version on this site. In Portuguese and English.
How do I get it?
Right after payment the ebook opens, and we email you a link that works on any device.
Do I get an invoice?
Yes, an invoice by email. You can add your tax number at checkout.
Where does the data come from?
From the platforms, the law and published studies, and from our own database of listings in Portugal. Every number says where it comes from and its sample.